How IRA Withdrawals and Property Sales Can Increase Your Medicare Premiums

A retirement distribution or the sale of a property could increase your Medicare premiums two years later. Here’s how IRMAA works—and why Medicare decisions should be coordinated with your tax and financial plan.

We joined Fox 13’s Good Day Tampa Bay to discuss how not coordinating your retirement plan with your Medicare planning could be an expensive mistake. Click on the link below to watch the segment

Fox 13 Medicare Segment

Imagine you’re retired and decide to withdraw $150,000 from your traditional IRA to help purchase a vacation home. Or perhaps you sell an investment property you’ve owned for decades and realize a substantial capital gain.

You understand that the transaction may affect your income taxes. What you might not realize is that it could also increase your Medicare premiums.

For higher-income Medicare beneficiaries, a provision known as the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, or IRMAA, can add hundreds or even thousands of dollars to annual Medicare costs.

The surprising part? The higher premiums generally don’t appear immediately. Medicare typically uses tax return information from two years earlier to determine whether you owe an income-related surcharge.

This is one reason Medicare planning should be coordinated with retirement income planning, tax planning, and investment decisions.

What Is IRMAA?

IRMAA stands for Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount. It’s an additional charge that certain Medicare beneficiaries pay when their income exceeds thresholds established by the federal government.

IRMAA can increase the monthly premiums for:

  • Medicare Part B, which generally covers physician services, outpatient care, and other medical services.
  • Medicare Part D, which covers prescription drugs through eligible drug plans.

IRMAA is separate from your plan’s normal premium. Depending on your income, the surcharge can meaningfully increase your total healthcare costs. A large sale, bonus, distribution, etc can increase your Part B Premium from $200 a month to nearly $700 a month. Your Part D coverage can move from a $0 monthly premium to over $90 a month in premiums. 

Importantly, IRMAA isn’t determined solely by your retirement salary or monthly pension. Certain one-time financial transactions can increase the income Medicare uses to calculate the surcharge.

How Does Medicare Determine IRMAA?

Medicare generally looks at your modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI, from your federal income tax return filed two years earlier.

For IRMAA purposes, MAGI generally means your adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest income.

Your filing status also matters. The income thresholds differ for married couples filing jointly, married individuals filing separately in certain circumstances, and single filers.

If your income exceeds the applicable threshold, you may pay an additional amount for Part B and Part D.

Because the thresholds and surcharge amounts can change annually, it’s important to review the figures that apply to the specific year you’re planning for.

Why the two-year lookback matters

The two-year lookback can create a disconnect between your current financial situation and your Medicare premiums.

For example, a transaction that increases your taxable income in 2026 could affect your Medicare premiums in 2028.

You might have retired, reduced your income, or stopped taking large distributions by then. Nevertheless, Medicare may still use your 2026 tax return to determine your income-related premiums for 2028.

That timing is particularly important when planning large financial transactions in retirement.

Scenario #1: A Large IRA Withdrawal Triggers Higher Medicare Premiums

Consider John and Mary, a hypothetical retired couple who have accumulated substantial savings in traditional IRAs.

They want to purchase a vacation property and decide to withdraw $200,000 from John’s traditional IRA to help fund the purchase.

John and Mary understand that the withdrawal may increase their federal income taxes. However, they don’t consider how the additional income could affect their Medicare premiums.

A traditional IRA distribution is generally taxable as ordinary income, except to the extent it represents a nontaxable amount, such as a return of after-tax basis.

The distribution could push the couple’s modified adjusted gross income above an IRMAA threshold.

If it does, they could face higher Part B and Part D premiums two years later.

The exact impact depends on their other income, tax filing status, the applicable IRMAA thresholds, and the size of the taxable distribution.

What could they have done differently?

Before withdrawing the money, John and Mary could have evaluated several options:

  • Determine how much of the IRA withdrawal would be taxable.
  • Estimate their projected modified adjusted gross income.
  • Review the IRMAA thresholds for the relevant Medicare premium year.
  • Consider whether the purchase could be funded through other assets or a different withdrawal strategy.
  • Evaluate whether spreading distributions across multiple tax years would better fit their overall financial plan.

None of these alternatives is automatically better. The right choice depends on their taxes, cash flow, investment allocation, and other financial objectives.

The key is to evaluate the potential tax and Medicare consequences before taking a large distribution.

Scenario #2: Selling an Investment Property Increases Medicare Costs

Now consider Robert, a retired homeowner who owns a rental property that he purchased many years ago.

The property has appreciated substantially, and Robert decides to sell it to simplify his finances in retirement.

The sale generates a significant gain.

Robert expects to pay capital gains tax, but he doesn’t realize that the taxable gain could also affect his Medicare premiums.

Why a property sale can affect IRMAA

The amount of cash you receive from selling a property is not necessarily the amount of income recognized for tax purposes.

The taxable gain generally depends on factors such as the property’s adjusted tax basis, selling expenses, capital improvements, depreciation, and applicable tax rules.

For rental or investment property, depreciation recapture rules may also apply.

The taxable gain recognized from the sale can increase adjusted gross income and, consequently, the income Medicare uses to determine IRMAA.

For example, if Robert recognizes a large taxable gain in 2026, that income could affect his Medicare premiums in 2028.

This can happen even if Robert no longer has the property or the associated rental income when those higher premiums begin.

What should property owners consider before selling?

Before completing a significant real estate transaction, consider:

  • Estimating the property’s taxable gain with a qualified tax professional.
  • Reviewing how the gain could affect your projected income and IRMAA.
  • Considering whether the timing of the sale is flexible.
  • Evaluating how the sale fits into your retirement income and investment strategy.
  • Reviewing the potential effects of depreciation recapture and other applicable tax rules.

A sale should not automatically be delayed or divided into installments solely to avoid IRMAA. Tax consequences, transaction costs, investment risks, and personal objectives all matter.

But understanding the potential Medicare impact before selling can help you make a more informed decision.

Other Financial Decisions That Can Affect IRMAA

IRA withdrawals and property sales aren’t the only financial transactions that can affect Medicare premiums.

Depending on the circumstances, the following may increase the income used to calculate IRMAA:

Roth conversions: Converting money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA generally creates taxable income in the year of the conversion. That additional income may increase future Medicare premiums.

Capital gains from investments: Selling appreciated stocks, mutual funds, or other investments can generate taxable capital gains that affect your income.

Required minimum distributions: Traditional IRA and other eligible retirement account owners generally must begin taking required minimum distributions when applicable. These distributions can increase taxable income and potentially affect IRMAA.

Bonuses, business income, and other taxable income: Significant income in a particular year can affect the calculation, depending on the applicable tax rules.

The common thread is that financial decisions made for one purpose can have consequences elsewhere in your retirement plan.

Can You Appeal an IRMAA Determination?

Sometimes, yes.

If Social Security determines that you owe IRMAA, you may be able to request a new determination in certain circumstances.

One important consideration is whether you’ve experienced a qualifying life-changing event that reduced your income.

Recognized events can include retirement or work stoppage, a reduction in work, the death of a spouse, divorce or annulment, and certain other qualifying circumstances.

If eligible, you can generally ask Social Security to reconsider your determination using Form SSA-44 or another applicable process.

However, a large IRA withdrawal or a capital gain from selling a property does not automatically qualify as a life-changing event for an IRMAA appeal. A one-time increase in income may still count when Medicare calculates your premiums.

If you receive an IRMAA determination that you believe is incorrect, review the notice and contact Social Security about your options and deadlines.

How to Coordinate Medicare and Financial Planning

The most effective approach is to consider Medicare before making significant financial decisions—not after higher premiums arrive.

At Mosaic Financial, we believe retirement planning should bring together five key areas: income, investments, taxes, healthcare, and legacy planning.

Here’s how these areas can work together.

1. Project your income before taking large distributions

Before making a large IRA withdrawal or Roth conversion, estimate your taxable income and modified adjusted gross income for the year.

Include your expected pension income, Social Security benefits, investment income, and other relevant items.

2. Consider future Medicare premiums

Look beyond the current year. Because IRMAA generally uses a two-year lookback, today’s income decisions may affect your Medicare costs in a future year.

3. Coordinate with your tax professional

Your financial advisor and tax professional can help evaluate the tax consequences of a distribution, Roth conversion, or property sale.

The goal is to understand the combined effects rather than optimizing one decision in isolation.

4. Evaluate the entire retirement plan

Avoiding an IRMAA surcharge isn’t necessarily the most important financial objective.

For example, a Roth conversion may increase your current income and future Medicare premiums but still make sense as part of a long-term tax strategy.

Similarly, selling a property may be the right decision even if it creates a temporary IRMAA increase.

The goal is to make decisions that support your broader financial objectives—not simply to avoid a particular surcharge.

Frequently Asked Questions About IRMAA

Does a large IRA withdrawal increase Medicare premiums?

It can. A taxable traditional IRA distribution may increase the modified adjusted gross income Medicare uses to determine IRMAA. Because Medicare generally uses tax information from two years earlier, the premium impact often appears later.

Can selling a house increase Medicare premiums?

It depends on the property and the taxable gain. Selling your primary residence may qualify for an exclusion of some or all of the gain if the applicable requirements are met. Any taxable gain that remains may affect IRMAA. Gains from investment or rental property may also increase the income used for the calculation.

Does a Roth conversion affect IRMAA?

Yes, potentially. A Roth conversion generally increases taxable income in the year it occurs, which can increase Medicare premiums in a later year.

Can I avoid IRMAA by appealing?

An appeal or request for a new determination may be available in certain circumstances, particularly following a qualifying life-changing event that reduces income. However, a one-time taxable transaction by itself does not automatically qualify for relief.

Should I avoid taking money from my IRA to keep Medicare premiums low?

Not necessarily. Retirement withdrawals should be evaluated based on taxes, income needs, investment strategy, and long-term financial objectives. Avoiding an IRMAA surcharge is one consideration, not the only consideration.

Plan Ahead for Medicare and Retirement Income

Your Medicare premiums can be affected by decisions you make years earlier. That’s why it’s important to understand how IRA distributions, Roth conversions, property sales, and other financial transactions may influence your future healthcare costs.

Coordinating these decisions can help you anticipate expenses, make informed choices, and avoid surprises in retirement.

At Mosaic Financial, we help retirees bring the pieces of their financial lives together.

Schedule a complimentary 45-minute Medicare appointment to discuss your coverage options and how healthcare costs fit into your broader retirement plan. Click below to schedule your meeting.

Medicare Meeting

Call 813-502-1228 to get started.

Important Disclosure: Mosaic Financial Group and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal, or accounting advice. IRMAA thresholds and premiums are subject to change. Individual tax and Medicare outcomes depend on your circumstances. Consult qualified professionals regarding your individual situation.

Mosaic Financial Group and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction. This presentation is provided solely for informational purposes and is not intended as and should not be considered specific investment or financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any securities. No investment decision should be made based solely on the information contained in this bulletin. The opinions referenced herein are as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice. Investing in securities involves risk, including the possibility of loss of principal capital. Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where Continuum Advisory and its investment adviser representatives are properly licensed or otherwise exempt. Investment Advisory Services offered through Continuum Advisory, LLC, a Registered Investment Adviser.  Mosaic Financial Group and Continuum Advisory, LLC are not affiliated.

Ready to take The Next Step?

For more information about any of our products and services, schedule a meeting today!

Or give us a call at 813.502.1228.